![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=d49e55596cf40ad115e4c7eb672d1151/b79d08381f30e924667cfe505b086e061c95f709.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_0303458a8372a9f91c9a0049414e632e)
本贴为B站视频的完善和补充,单仍需结合视频观看。
随着ITX渐渐走入大众的生活,小型化也成为了一种风格,市面上出现了许多A4机箱,他们都有一个特点,就是对机箱空间的极致压缩,为了让各个硬件之间严丝合缝,导致了散热器的体积不能太大,然而市面上种类繁多的ITX散热器让各位玩家挑花了眼,也不知道自己是否选对了产品。
本期将对18款65mm以下的下压式散热器进行横向对比,希望能给各位一个大致的选择方向, 一款散热器的好坏不是由温度单一决定的,所以这次横评采用打分制,对每款的产品包装,散热器本体及配件做工,对内存和主板兼容度,安装难度,待机和单烤时的温度与噪音情况(由你们自己打分),这五项来进行综合评比。每项评分占5分,一共25分。
测试平台的配置,CPU为Ryzen 3700x,主板使用华硕的B450 I,测试在T03拆除外框的骨架上,模拟开放平台,测试环境温度控制在20°,3700x锁定3.9ghz,电压1.2v,主板防掉压三级,风扇转速由主板pwm默认控制,单烤AIDA64的fpu10分钟,清除前5分钟的数据,硅脂涂法为刮腻子涂法,测试顺序由价格从低到高进行。
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=0be7fc936a1ed21b79c92eed9d6fddae/f7859912c8fcc3ce4f8ea4528545d688d53f209e.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_37909fbccf5cfd6ac57719043f875def)
下面先摆结果图
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=a4a4528075d9f2d3201124e799ed8a53/afa5c924b899a901935836570a950a7b0308f5fc.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_ef4960bf0753edb15a3bdb4ee0471366)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=0b7b8c5622fae6cd0cb4ab693fb20f9e/6d5171da81cb39db2aad0a37c7160924aa1830f3.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_9e812fdaf7b660c785766cb45d37e4df)
首先是ID-COLLING IS-40X
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=f0e28f9b6ccb0a4685228b315b63f63e/f3834d224f4a20a4ba3251a687529822720ed03d.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_22a82bd3c20767e833b1c1958a06b195)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=a723f0d7de177f3e1034fc0540ce3bb9/321e861ea8d3fd1f37dfc05b274e251f94ca5f16.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_aaf24e5e539d31b0772957cd04a8f4c1)
支持平台:
INTEL:115X
AMD:FM2(+) AM2(+) AM3(+) AM4
固定方式为四颗螺丝固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=123003e4deea15ce41eee00186003a25/aad9710fd9f9d72a71527d7cc32a2834349bbb36.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_87c88a1252d72c37796d37f78e618e8f)
6mm*4热管,底座为热管直触,鳍片之间采用穿FIN工艺,Is 40x 的底面打磨的不行,热管与底座还有高低差与缝隙。
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=d49155596cf40ad115e4c7eb672d1151/b79d08381f30e9246673fe505b086e061c95f716.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_835f0d184d63a04228a9669c60f7623c)
风扇数据: NO-9215-SD,2500RPM,44.3CFM,液压轴承, 无减震垫,两年保修
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=84205d17e51fbe091c5ec31c5b610c30/ffdf00a4462309f76fb9cf73650e0cf3d6cad617.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_0ec9ca1afa3f84cde16f4f8d46933980)
热管和鳍片进行黑化处理,鳍片间采用用折FIN固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e74c8e62df95d143da76e42b43f18296/1b8db72bd40735fa43262cd889510fb30e240816.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_6cfc33e0d06f10d5e35d5edc789fb3fe)
本体重162g
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=d6281e721ef79052ef1f47363cf2d738/e1a8069759ee3d6da377eaaa54166d224e4adeb0.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_9ce0c29e042bc1a1e814be939ae1394f)
乔思伯 HP-400
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=2bc1837b3f34349b74066e8df9eb1521/dbf52c338744ebf814a0065ecef9d72a6159a717.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_e4eba8bd9f24a192a459398ac52934b7)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=11d70ce4deea15ce41eee00186013a25/aad9710fd9f9d72a72b5727cc32a2834359bbb17.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_1c05507c6f7f21c1299120fb2d98d469)
支持平台:INTEL:775 115X
AMD:FM1 FM2 AM2(+) AM3(+) AM4
固定方式为四颗螺丝固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=7fdf9fc4c643ad4ba62e46c8b2035a89/27bef40735fae6cddd65c90018b30f2443a70f17.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_525db562b89ca3c8fe5e833e3f5a14f1)
6mm*4热管,底座为镜面铜底,鳍片之间为穿FIN工艺
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e4ea096c319759ee4a5060c382fb434e/e7b931dfa9ec8a138f373a81e003918fa0ecc03c.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_62f63ae6b6719a6dacee098a1d4c4463)
风扇数据:CF-D9215H,3000RPM,59.83CFM,液压轴承, 无减震垫,一年保修
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=75f7e700ef1986184147ef8c7aec2e69/7f693e178a82b9018c7ca152648da9773812ef10.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_c1584b40b817a56924e3846ae55906d9)
热管和鳍片进行镀镍处理,鳍片间无固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e516066c319759ee4a5060c382fa434e/e7b931dfa9ec8a138ecb3581e003918fa1ecc010.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_97171af39fc4664fba435939ba6a410f)
本体重135g
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=f606fc5e5cfbfbeddc59367748f1f78e/bfb162a7d933c8957deaf51ac61373f083020054.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_43f4fcf270248b2a2f9d707fece54bce)
酷鱼 Z39
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=8df31665800a304e5222a0f2e1c9a7c3/dc14a00a19d8bc3ec1d964ab958ba61ea9d34517.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_e9e385044de7926735220a3d26e99117)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=113f007d06dfa9ecfd2e561f52d1f754/19946c086e061d95e99755596cf40ad163d9ca10.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_a196549aa8be4a9c56e17c5224bb66e3)
支持平台:INTEL:775 115X
AMD:FM1 FM2 AM2 AM3(+) AM4
固定方式为四颗螺丝固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=1a30f49d6bd98d1076d40c39113eb807/e91792b7d0a20cf405409cbe61094b36adaf9910.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_5f7fa0b4f054e0dfa1ce3976fd8422e1)
6mm*4热管,底座为热管直触,热管与鳍片穿FIN工艺,Z39的底面打磨较为平整,但是还有缝隙
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=bafe56b82e01213fcf334ed464e636f8/bc6111adcbef76097cd8fbfe39dda3cc7dd99e11.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_6a26fd8f8ed4f911184f30176128641d)
风扇数据:CF-D9215H,3000RPM,45CFM,单面减震垫,一年保
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e3164d1d460fd9f9a0175561152cd42b/cb5e2a46f21fbe09638da1757c600c338644ad11.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_044bc5f85dce9b3c99e3079f1b96a0e0)
热管和鳍片无处理,鳍片间采用用扣FIN固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=ef66f14fbfd3fd1f3609a232004f25ce/2c17f158ccbf6c81ede74e89ab3eb13532fa4010.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_1f4031f30d5445c1b5134f96195a33c1)
本体重152g
压力测试这款的时候忘了截图
ID-COLLIGN IS-50X
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=7fde9fc4c643ad4ba62e46c8b2035a89/27bef40735fae6cddd64c90018b30f2443a70f10.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_978c1b5ea62f7e63ca6b61c551d5cd82)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=9f41798cb4cc7cd9fa2d34d109002104/1da17982b2b7d0a23f1a66fcdcef76094a369a11.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_bccc2db8b767526110ba327428c99ba4)
支持平台:INTEL:115XAMD:AM4固定方式为四颗螺丝固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=4ac150593f381f309e198da199004c67/6a216aed2e738bd467f2d050b68b87d6267ff912.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_0e641317003563ab99ada0da848d91e8)
6mm*5热管,底座为热管直触,鳍片之间采用穿FIN工艺,IS-50X的底面打磨非常平整,快赶上镜面了
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e2bfa48fa38f8c54e3d3c5270a282dee/35a0c5dde71190ef3b28f0bed91b9d16fcfa6011.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_16e0477d4c39f77eb64c63bd42327578)
风扇数据: NO-12015,1600RPM,53.6CFM,液压轴承, 无减震垫,两年保修
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=dbb347694443fbf2c52ca62b807fca1e/797f35ce36d3d539abef6da22d87e950342ab012.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_2402a8d15b90935c7a003804f5e19056)
热管和鳍片进行黑化处理,鳍片间采用用折FIN固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=5538702e892f07085f052a08d925b865/368d167adab44aedfc9ddc85a41c8701a08bfb12.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_69d9e5dfaa11f63f24cc49cedceea33d)
本体重227g
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=f5a7c67e10082838680ddc1c8898a964/86effab44aed2e73590ceb4d9001a18b86d6fa04.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_37105bc37a82e6d071160f4d7b56712f)
兼容性:可以兼容幻光戟这种高马甲内存,不过最高就是幻光戟,不能再高了
大镰刀 十手 JT-8039
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=4a36da4116e9390156028d364bed54f9/60372cf431adcbef40e61c67bbaf2edda2cc9f12.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_b6865c1426399dc7455584c477b5e7e8)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=c1dab28cf01190ef01fb92d7fe1a9df7/089b5bec54e736d16bc1ee698c504fc2d4626912.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_f5c57598656dde89a1d0af9548a44b58)
支持平台:INTEL:775 115XAMD:FM1 FM2(+) AM2(+) AM3(+) AM4固定方式为四颗螺丝固定多一套风扇扣具可增加第二把8010风扇
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e5e5671f321f95caa6f592bef9167fc5/a94d9c3eb13533faf064f14fbfd3fd1f40345b12.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_387448e637a9c6e7a0e7fa48a6478337)
6mm*4热管,底座为镜面铜底,回流焊工艺,鳍片之间为穿FIN工艺,JT-8039的镜面比HP400的高一个档次
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=0bf6bc95a04543a9f51bfac42e168a7b/fb6edbedab64034fc01fa067b8c379310b551d12.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_f92659acee083a2d4d933805796f2e70)
风扇数据:SC8010,3000RPM,25.8CFM,套筒轴承,无减震垫,一年保修
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=b1a02fa1e036afc30e0c3f6d8318eb85/1ddef11373f08202e840f35e5cfbfbedaa641b12.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_767c0b3c1461c1da8729e3fe89283359)
热管和鳍片进行镀镍处理,鳍片间采用扣FIN固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=cb1fa067b8c379317d688621dbc5b784/618653f082025aaf17e01caaecedab64024f1a12.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_57a4b64e5f4d83c144a1c4e14699a356)
本体重219g
大镰刀风扇不适合原装那样加在热管与散热鳍片之间吸风,所以我测了两组数据,第一组是原装状态,第二组是风扇拿出来固定在散热鳍片上面,类似乔思伯HP-400
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=46ca9aaceb039245a1b5e107b794a4a8/2fa8d8dcd100baa148152bda5010b912c8fc2e2f.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_4a95f1de5581d080d1422328c94f120e)
原装
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=1a418fd9c33f8794d3ff4826e21b0ead/0a34ed11728b4710311691add4cec3fdfc03232f.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_3668091e1806673759061f59766d334f)
风扇上置
ID COLLING IS-60(有兼容问题)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=e8fa4e89ab3eb13544c7b7b3961fa8cb/6dc1764e9258d109db2ecbd3c658ccbf6d814d13.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_48640789b3e11c571cd58219bcdccc36)
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=dbda3708322dd42a5f0901a3333a5b2f/dbf6d6246b600c338bb4bca90d4c510fd8f9a113.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_2631c6353b8d02e85e952a2c6fc26588)
支持平台:INTEL:115XAMD:FM2(+) AM2(+) AM3(+) AM4固定方式为四颗螺丝固定多一套标准12cm风扇固定螺丝,可更换标准12cm风扇
![](https://imgsa.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=ccb06a7a6c2762d0803ea4b790ed0849/ad002a7b02087bf46f8d82b0fdd3572c10dfcf98.jpg)
6mm*6热管,底座为镜面铜底,鳍片之间采用穿FIN工艺,IS-60的镜面比前两个都好
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=04bb864264f082022d9291377bfafb8a/56585b899e510fb3a6d415f6ce33c895d0430c13.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_ad23d63b4bed8bfab8c442703e90621b)
风扇数据: NO-12015,1600RPM,53.6CFM,液压轴承, 无减震垫,两年保修
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=3e9e8a9546da81cb4ee683c56267d0a4/22d0f688d43f879437322a4fc51b0ef41ad53a13.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_9cc81277d6d1f3e2ad818f77da5c3a17)
热管和鳍片进行镀镍处理,鳍片间采用用扣FIN固定
![](http://tiebapic.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=f859d577d8fc1e17fdbf8c397a91f67c/b3da58f0f736afc3c2c15d04a419ebc4b6451213.jpg?tbpicau=2025-03-01-05_d1f61c9866bb5a1db0d9bd5643de3391)
本体重317g
![](https://imgsa.baidu.com/forum/w%3D580/sign=ec4f834e6dd0f703e6b295d438fb5148/baee22087bf40ad1048512ba582c11dfa8ecce98.jpg)
兼容性问题:不支持高马甲内存
发不下了我看看是另发帖还是跟楼